It is not a difference of opinion when an opinion is rooted in the faith of the person who holds that opinion. It’s also not even an opinion. It is a belief.
Too few people understand this important difference, but it is one that has been intentionally obscured by the people who stand to benefit from the distinction being lost entirely.
The Bill of Rights comprises the first ten amendments to the Constitution. The first clause – known as the Establishment Clause – works in conjunction with the Exercise Clause to make the beginning of the First Amendment, which states that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof….”
The Founding Fathers intended for this to create a separation of church and state.
This isn’t really negotiable or up for debate, no matter who tries to tell you otherwise and no matter who has tried to water it down over the centuries. Those people are either the dictionary definition of ignorant, or they are not acting in good faith at all and their motives are not to be trusted.
This couldn’t possibly be clearer than when Colorado Representative Lauren Boebert said last Sunday, “I’m tired of this separation of church and state junk.”
She acknowledges that the phrase was written in a letter Thomas Jefferson penned to the Danbury Baptists, but doesn’t acknowledge that the discussion did not end there – that the founder of Rhode Island, Roger Williams, agreed with him and founded Rhode Island for that very purpose, or that James Madison also agreed with Jefferson, or that they had the support of various Anglican faiths who wanted their freedom secured as much as secular people. This (among other things) is also an important part of why churches do not pay taxes. This is all well documented.
White supremacist ideas in the United States have their roots in American Christianity. This, too, is well documented.
The Civil Rights Acts that were passed throughout the sixties forced conservative politicians to shift their focus to something else in the seventies, otherwise they would start to lose power and become obsolete.
After 1973, that focus became making abortion illegal, and they enlisted evangelical white Christians to make it happen.
Over the past week, Roe has been overturned because extreme Christian zealotry has seeped into every aspect of American life and is forcing those who are not Christian to live according to Christian beliefs.
SCOTUS also ruled 6–3 that a football coach had the right to have his entire team take a knee on the field after a game and pray. At a public school funded by federal dollars.
If the coach had been Muslim and put down a prayer rug in the center of the field, Christians would have lost their fucking minds and the ruling would have gone the other way, if it even made it to SCOTUS at all.
How would any of the teammates who did not wish to take a knee and pray to the Christian god be treated by the coach? The rest of the team? The community? These are other people’s children. We all know the answers to those questions.
Our democracy has slowly crumbled over the past five decades and progressives have lost the ability to wield power due to gerrymandering, voter disenfranchisement, neoliberalism gaining a foothold, the rise of evangelical Christianity, and the GOP playing the long game.
A very important component of that long game was ensuring that the right people would be put in power and chip away at the wall of separation SO gradually, that by the time it was completely torn down, it would be too late.
And it is really feeling like the wall is completely gone and it is way, way too fucking late.
—emily duchaine
Flommist Emily Duchaine lives in the Pacific Northwest. She likes to drink mead, learn about sharks, and listen to the Talking Heads. She pretends to be a professional businesswoman most days. Copyright © 2022 Emily Duchaine.
PLEASE SUPPORT FLOMM
TIPS + DONATIONS DISCREETLY ACCEPTED