Everyone is laughing at that picture of all the women sitting behind Kavanaugh making ‘WTF’ faces, and they should be. It IS funny, and I’m never one to tell people they shouldn’t be laughing. Humor is important. When we lose our ability to laugh, we will truly be dead.
I just want to ask that you all think about something, and I speak from experience with this: As funny as their facial expressions are, those are the right facial expressions for them to have. They are entirely appropriate. Those women are reacting precisely the way they should to the situation, and their faces are conveying those reactions because that’s what human faces do.
Women are told all the time not to let their emotions show on their faces. Or show at all, period. All too often, any reaction is written off as an overreaction. Getting angry, upset, frustrated, confused, shocked, disgusted – anything that can’t be classified as ‘happy’ and ‘agreeable’ – is considered an ‘attitude’ that women are told they should simply just change, and then everything will be better.
Motivational posters with pretty pictures and quotes about attitudes are not intended for men. Trust me, men don’t really care about that shit. They don’t have to, and they aren’t really expected to care, either.
That idea – that you are in control of your attitude and a change in attitude changes everything – is intended for women, and it’s a form of gaslighting. It subtly implies, “Your attitude is what’s making things difficult for you – not the injustices you’re facing, not the unfair way things are being done, not the obvious disparities in power and control and status, not the system being rigged against you because you are not adequately represented – it’s your attitude, and the ONLY thing you GET to be in control of is your attitude, so GET it under control and change it fast.”
When you don’t want to go to a party because you think the hosts are bad cooks and it’s boring over there and they always want to play scrabble and you don’t like scrabble, yeah, that’s a bad attitude. You’re just being a whiner. This is absolutely one of those scenarios where you should try to be more positive: You have friends who like you enough to share their time, food, and interests with you. That’s precious. So just in case anyone doesn’t get what I’m trying to say here, I’m NOT saying there’s no such thing as a bad attitude or that people (men or women) don’t ever have one.
What I AM saying is that women are people, and people react, and when people react, they show those reactions on their faces. And most of the time, people react to things in a way that’s absolutely reasonable.
If you really want to simplify this concept, just think about how often women are told to smile, compared to how often men are told to smile. I look as hilariously stupid trying to force a fake smile as I do trying to pretend to look angry when I’m not. Ask my husband Aaron. When I’m playing at being angry just to be a goof, I’m not fooling anyone. He knows it.
When my smile is genuine, it’s because I’m feeling genuinely happy. So when I look pissed off, or sad, or disgusted, it’s probably because I am genuinely experiencing those things for very real reasons, and because I’m a human being with real emotions and feelings, I’m going to show it.
There was nothing to smile about yesterday.
—emily duchaine
Flommist Emily Duchaine lives in the Pacific Northwest. She likes to drink mead, learn about sharks, and listen to the Talking Heads. She pretends to be a professional businesswoman most days. Copyright © 2018 Emily Duchaine.
PLEASE SUPPORT FLOMM
TIPS + DONATIONS DISCREETLY ACCEPTED