“the virtue of your style inscribed on your contempt for mine.”
—Joni Mitchell
In the midst of a discussion,
at a party,
in the middle of the street,
maybe in the middle of a gyros,
civilized right up until that record-scratch:
“you like what – ?”
Buried beneath the sudden slag of recommendations, entreaties and missives to check out this, that or the other – your personal taste has become a cause for alarm.
I get loving something. I get wanting to share it with someone else. What I don’t get is the caliber of your taste has to fit in with a mathematical formula someone else buys into.
Surely, the noble pedagog postulates, I can only like such an inferior product because I have not yet sampled the sum of good taste. I have only to add the recommendations they thrust into my sweaty little palms, subtract my inferior likes, and simply multiply their opinion until I reach the same answer. Because I am simply adrift in a sea of unfiltered information, a naive little lamb at worst and a troglodytic contrarian at best.
It might never occur to these concerned citizens that the person they are denouncing like a witch at an inquisition may in fact have read the same things they read, listened to the same songs, watched the same movies and – shock! horror! – arrive on their own to a completely different conclusion than anyone else’s. Or that I might not be any more enriched by your suggestion than you would be by mine.
Because this is the metric that society sets before us: If you are a good person, you must like good things. Ergo, if you are a good person who likes uncool things, you are not really a good person. Unless you enjoy it on that most loathsome and overused and misapplied of levels – ironically. Then and only then are you allowed to express enjoyment of the inferior thing.
Well, enough I say. You’ve got a freak flag, fuckin’ fly it.
Your favorite movie is Barbie and the Diamond Castle?
Good, own that shit.
You were one of the three people to buy Linkin Park’s last album?
Headbang that noise in public.
You actually enjoyed the Fifty Shades trilogy?
Well, hypothetically, while I find your personal choice odious to the extreme, I will defend to the death your right to get down.
Because contempt for an opinion that’s out of step isn’t superior, it’s insincere. It implies reality is a consensus view, and that good things are determined by popular vote. Well, taste is not democratic, republic, hell, it isn’t even oligarchic. It’s a monarchy, and you are the tyrant that determines the lay of the land.
It’s an old romance, the opinion dance, and hasn’t gone to sleep.
—rachel gardner
Flommist Rachel Gardner currently writes weird fiction with a horror bent. Find her at Greetings from the Wasteland, which updates weekly. Copyright © 2015 Rachel Gardner. Photo: Moderately-used Linkin Park CD, found at a bus stop.
PLEASE SUPPORT FLOMM
TIPS + DONATIONS DISCREETLY ACCEPTED